Amish Exclusive vs Arhaus in Rochester, NY
100% American-made solid hardwood furniture, built by Amish artisans, not sourced globally.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Amish Exclusive | Arhaus |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturing | 100% USA, handcrafted by Amish artisans | Mixed: North Carolina facility plus global sourcing (Mexico, Indonesia, India, Italy) |
| Wood Quality | Solid hardwood throughout: oak, cherry, maple, walnut, hickory | Varies: solid wood, reclaimed wood, and mixed-material depending on collection |
| Customization | Full custom: choose wood species, stain, dimensions, and hardware | Fabric and finish selections within preset designs |
| Construction | Traditional joinery: mortise-and-tenon, dovetail joints, hand-fitted | Varies by collection and manufacturing source |
| Price Range | $$, competitive pricing for solid hardwood | $$$, premium lifestyle brand pricing |
| Local Showroom | Webster, NY, 15 min from downtown Rochester | Eastview Mall, Victor, NY |
| Delivery | Rochester area delivery and white-glove setup | In-home delivery available |
Why Rochester Families Choose Amish Exclusive Over Arhaus
Know Exactly Where Your Furniture Comes From
Arhaus offers a styled lifestyle aesthetic with pieces sourced from artisans around the world. It's a beautiful approach, but it means your dining table might come from Indonesia while your chairs come from North Carolina. At Amish Exclusive, every piece is handcrafted in the USA by Amish artisans. You'll know exactly who built your furniture and where.
Solid Hardwood, Every Piece, Every Time
Arhaus collections span a wide range of materials including solid wood, reclaimed wood, mixed materials, metals, and more. At Amish Exclusive, we focus on what we do best: solid hardwood furniture. Every piece is built from premium kiln-dried hardwood with traditional joinery. No mixed materials, no compromises on construction.
Custom-Built, Not Selected From a Catalog
Arhaus offers fabric and finish choices within their collections, but the designs themselves are fixed. At Amish Exclusive, customization means choosing your wood species, stain color, dimensions, and hardware, or even modifying the design itself. Our Amish artisans build to your specifications, not a catalog template.
What We Have in Common with Arhaus
Arhaus shares our belief that furniture should be thoughtfully crafted and built to last. Their commitment to sustainability and artisan craftsmanship resonates with the same values that drive Amish furniture making. Both companies offer an alternative to disposable, mass-produced furniture.
Where We Stand Apart
100% American Made
Every piece handcrafted in the USA by Amish artisans. No overseas components.
Full Customization
Choose wood, stain, dimensions, hardware, and design. Built to your specs.
Better Value
Direct from craftsmen. No middlemen, no designer markup, no brand premium.
See the Amish Exclusive Difference
Frequently Asked Questions
See the Difference in Person
Visit our showroom at 2045 Empire Blvd, Webster, NY
11am - 5pm Tue-Sat | 12pm - 4pm Sun | By Appointment Only Mon
Just 15 minutes from downtown Rochester