Amish Exclusive vs Stickley Furniture in Rochester, NY
Amish handcrafted furniture with full customization, delivering the craftsmanship you expect from Stickley at a better value.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Amish Exclusive | Stickley |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturing | 100% USA, handcrafted by Amish artisans | ~90% USA (Manlius, NY and Archdale, NC), some overseas |
| Wood Quality | Solid hardwood throughout: oak, cherry, maple, walnut, hickory | Solid wood on premium lines, primarily cherry, oak, walnut |
| Customization | Full custom: choose wood species, stain, dimensions, and hardware | Limited, primarily finish selection within set collections |
| Construction | Traditional joinery: mortise-and-tenon, dovetail joints, hand-fitted | High-quality factory production with hand-finishing |
| Price Range | $$, competitive pricing for solid hardwood | $$$$, ultra-premium pricing reflecting brand heritage |
| Local Showroom | Webster, NY, 15 min from downtown Rochester | East Avenue, Rochester (Stickley Audi & Co.) |
| Delivery | Rochester area delivery and white-glove setup | White-glove delivery available |
Why Rochester Families Choose Amish Exclusive Over Stickley
Same Commitment to American Craftsmanship, More Flexibility
Stickley has earned its reputation with over 125 years of American furniture making, and we respect that legacy. Like Stickley, Amish Exclusive is committed to American-made, solid wood furniture. The difference is flexibility: while Stickley offers beautiful fixed collections, our Amish artisans build each piece to your exact specifications: your choice of wood, stain, size, and hardware.
Direct From the Craftsman, Better Value
Stickley's pricing reflects their brand heritage, retail presence, and 125-year legacy, and it's well-earned. At Amish Exclusive, we work directly with Amish craftsmen, cutting out layers of overhead. The result is comparable or superior solid hardwood construction at a significantly lower price point. You're paying for the wood and the craftsmanship, not the brand name.
Beyond Mission Style
Stickley is synonymous with the Mission and Craftsman aesthetic, and they do it beautifully. But if your home calls for a different style (transitional, farmhouse, contemporary, or traditional), Amish Exclusive offers a broader range of designs. Our artisans can build in virtually any style, adapted to your home's unique character.
What We Have in Common with Stickley
Stickley is one of America's most respected furniture makers, with a 125-year tradition of quality that began right here in Upstate New York. Like Amish Exclusive, they believe in solid wood construction, American manufacturing, and furniture that lasts. Both companies represent the best of what American craftsmanship can offer.
Where We Stand Apart
100% American Made
Every piece handcrafted in the USA by Amish artisans. No overseas components.
Full Customization
Choose wood, stain, dimensions, hardware, and design. Built to your specs.
Better Value
Direct from craftsmen. No middlemen, no designer markup, no brand premium.
See the Amish Exclusive Difference
Frequently Asked Questions
See the Difference in Person
Visit our showroom at 2045 Empire Blvd, Webster, NY
11am - 5pm Tue-Sat | 12pm - 4pm Sun | By Appointment Only Mon
Just 15 minutes from downtown Rochester